Granny flats—self-contained dwellings built on the same block of land as a primary residence—are becoming increasingly popular among Australian investors. Whether you’re looking to house a teenager needing more independence, a family member wanting to be closer to loved ones, or simply aiming to boost your property income, adding a granny flat can be a compelling option.
But is it a solid investment strategy? Let’s explore the benefits, risks, regulations, and practical considerations so you can decide whether building a granny flat stacks up for your financial goals.
Why a Granny Flat Could Be a Good Investment
A granny flat can serve as a secondary income stream and may add value to your existing property. Here’s when it might be considered a worthwhile investment:
- Rental income potential – Renting it out can help cover mortgage repayments or generate extra cash flow.
- Tax benefits – You may be eligible to claim depreciation and other investment-related deductions.
- Equity boost – A well-designed granny flat can increase your property’s overall value.
- Buffer against interest rate hikes – The rental income can offset rising mortgage costs.
- Location advantage – Suburbs with high rental demand and low vacancy rates are ideal for this strategy.
- Flexible use – Can be leased long-term, listed as a short-term rental, or used by family members.
Risks and Drawbacks of Building a Granny Flat
Like any investment, granny flats come with downsides and limitations you need to understand upfront.
1. Unexpected Construction Costs
The initial build often exceeds budget. Hidden costs like site works, access restrictions, or upgrading utilities can quickly add up.
2. Council Restrictions
Not all local councils allow granny flats. Each area has its own zoning, size, and access rules. Getting council approval can be a detailed, sometimes lengthy process.
3. Limited Capital Growth
Granny flats are more common in lower socio-economic areas or outer suburbs, which historically show slower capital growth compared to inner-city locations.
Check out “Crunching the Numbers: Positive Cash Flow vs. Negative Gearing“
4. Overcapitalisation Risk
Spending $110,000–$200,000 on a granny flat doesn’t always translate into an equal increase in property value. Many lenders will value the property based on market demand, not construction cost.
5. Smaller Resale and Rental Market
Many buyers prefer a unified residence without a separate dwelling in the backyard. Likewise, some tenants avoid shared properties due to privacy concerns.
6. Longer Vacancy Periods
Two separate dwellings mean double the potential for vacancies. If either property becomes vacant, your income takes a hit.
7. No Subdivision
Granny flats must remain on the same land title as the main residence. You can’t sell them separately.
“Get your Access to our Fully Customisable Investment Property Research and Analytics Tool Now!”
What Are the Legal Requirements?
Each state and territory in Australia has its own set of rules. While states like New South Wales, Western Australia, and Tasmania have more flexible policies, others like Victoria, South Australia, and Queensland (unless renting to family) are stricter.
Common eligibility criteria include:
- Property must be in a residential zone
- Land size must be at least 450 sqm
- Only one granny flat per property
- Maximum internal floor area (typically 60 sqm)
- Separate pedestrian access is often required
Tip: Always confirm the latest rules with your local council before proceeding.
How Much Does It Cost to Build a Granny Flat?
Granny flat costs vary depending on design, materials, and location. Expect to pay between $110,000 to $200,000 for a functional, self-contained dwelling. Additional costs may include:
- Architectural and engineering fees
- Site surveys and soil tests
- Council application and approval fees
- Additional costs for sloped sites or poor access
You’ll also need to budget for potential issues like asbestos, structural upgrades, or utility connections.
Understanding the Tax Implications
If you’re building a granny flat as an income-producing investment, be prepared for tax consequences.
- Rental income is taxable and must be declared.
- Deductible expenses include depreciation, maintenance, loan interest, and insurance.
- Capital Gains Tax (CGT) may apply if the granny flat is rented to third parties. This could affect your main residence exemption.
CGT tips:
- Only the portion of the property that generates income is subject to CGT.
- The gain is calculated based on the increase in value since the granny flat was built.
- Properties held longer than 12 months may be eligible for a 50% CGT discount.
Speak with a qualified tax professional before going ahead.
Tips to Maximise ROI from a Granny Flat
- Research your suburb – Understand rental demand, vacancy rates, and local regulations.
- Get detailed quotes – Always compare multiple builders and request fixed-price contracts.
- Use existing equity – Consider refinancing your home loan to fund the build if you have sufficient equity.
- Keep it cohesive – Design the granny flat to match your main home in style and quality.
- Avoid crowding the yard – Preserve outdoor space and privacy to maintain appeal for future buyers.
- Understand the market – Make sure the area supports dual occupancy rentals.
Is It the Right Strategy for You?
Adding a granny flat to your investment property can be a savvy move—if done strategically. It can create a steady rental income, offer tax advantages, and even boost the property’s value. However, it also comes with legal complexities, cost risks, and resale limitations.
This strategy works best in the right suburb, with solid research, and a clear understanding of your long-term goals. For investors with the right property and plan in place, a granny flat could be a profitable addition to your portfolio.
