Selling Your House for More Than It’s Worth: Pros, Cons, and Risks

- Advertisement -

The idea of selling your house for more than it’s worth can be tempting. Who wouldn’t want to maximise their profit and get the best possible return on their investment? While it is possible to achieve this, it may be frowned upon by some in the real estate industry and can come with significant risks. In this article, we will explore the pros, cons, and risks associated with trying to up-sell your home. By understanding these factors, you can make an informed decision about whether this strategy is right for you.

Understanding Property Valuation

Market Value vs. Perceived Value

Market value is the price a buyer is willing to pay for a property under normal conditions. It’s determined by various factors, including the property’s location, size, condition, and recent sales of similar properties in the area. Perceived value, on the other hand, is more subjective and can be influenced by factors like the presentation of the home, current market trends, and buyer emotions.

Overpricing Defined

Overpricing means setting your home’s listing price higher than its market value. While some sellers might think this strategy will result in higher offers, it can backfire if not done correctly.

Pros of Selling Your House for More Than It’s Worth

Potential for Higher Profit

The primary advantage of overpricing your home is the potential for a higher selling price. If a buyer perceives the value of your home to be higher than the market value and is willing to pay the listed price, you can walk away with a larger profit.


  • Increased Return on Investment: More money in your pocket if the property sells at the higher price.
  • Funding Future Investments: Extra funds can be used for future investments or to buy a more expensive property.
  • Financial Cushion: Provides additional financial security.

Check out “Preparing Your Property for Sale & Achieving Your Top Dollar Goals

Creates Room for Negotiation

Setting a higher asking price can provide you with room to negotiate. Buyers often expect some negotiation and may offer below the asking price. Starting high allows you to come down to a price that is still above market value but acceptable to the buyer.


  • Negotiation Leverage: Allows you to meet buyers halfway while still achieving a favorable price.
  • Buyer Perception: Buyers may feel they’re getting a deal if they negotiate a lower price.
  • Seller Control: Keeps the seller in a stronger negotiating position.

Perceived Value

A higher price can sometimes create a perception of greater value. Buyers might assume that a higher-priced home has superior features or is in a better location compared to lower-priced homes.


  • Attracts Serious Buyers: Higher price points can attract serious buyers who are willing to pay more for perceived quality.
  • Market Positioning: Can position your home as a premium offering in the market.
  • Exclusive Appeal: Creates an air of exclusivity and desirability.

“Get your Access to our Fully Customisable Investment Property Research and Analytics Tool Now!”

Cons of Selling Your House for More Than It’s Worth

Extended Time on the Market

Overpriced homes tend to stay on the market longer. Buyers and agents often avoid listings they perceive as overpriced, leading to extended time on the market and potentially stigmatising the property.


  • Market Stigma: Homes that sit on the market too long can develop a stigma, making buyers wonder what’s wrong with the property.
  • Decreased Interest: Fewer showings and offers as buyers overlook the listing.
  • Financial Burden: Longer time on the market can mean ongoing costs such as mortgage payments, maintenance, and property taxes.

Appraisal Issues

Even if you find a buyer willing to pay your asking price, the deal can fall through if the property doesn’t appraise for that amount. Lenders rely on appraisals to determine how much they’re willing to finance. If the appraisal comes in lower than the purchase price, the buyer may not be able to secure financing.


  • Deal Collapse: Risk of the deal falling through if the buyer cannot secure financing.
  • Renegotiation: May need to renegotiate the price after the appraisal, potentially lowering your profit.
  • Seller Concessions: You may need to offer concessions to keep the deal alive.

Reduced Buyer Interest

Overpricing can deter potential buyers, who may skip over your listing in favor of more reasonably priced homes. This can result in fewer showings and offers, making it harder to sell your home.


  • Limited Exposure: Fewer buyers willing to view an overpriced property.
  • Missed Opportunities: Potentially missing out on qualified buyers who would have been interested at a lower price.
  • Competitive Disadvantage: Competing properties may seem more attractive and offer better value.

Impact on Future Sales

If you fail to sell your home at the higher price and have to lower it later, it can negatively impact future sales. Buyers may see the price reduction as a sign of desperation or that there’s something wrong with the property.


  • Price Reductions: Frequent price reductions can damage your credibility and market position.
  • Desperation Perception: Buyers may perceive desperation, leading to lower offers.
  • Lost Leverage: Reducing the price can weaken your negotiating position.

Check out “How to Control Emotions when Buying an Investment Property?

Risks of Overpricing Your Home

Market Changes

Real estate markets can fluctuate due to various factors, including economic conditions, interest rates, and local developments. If the market cools while your home is overpriced, you may find it even harder to sell.


  • Market Downturns: Market conditions can worsen, making it harder to sell.
  • Increased Competition: New listings at competitive prices can outshine your property.
  • Economic Uncertainty: Economic changes can impact buyer confidence and spending power.

Buyer Mistrust

Buyers and agents are often well-informed about market conditions. Overpricing can lead to mistrust, with buyers questioning your motives and the true value of the property.


  • Credibility Issues: Loss of credibility with buyers and agents.
  • Skepticism: Increased skepticism about the property’s condition and value.
  • Reputation Damage: Potential damage to your reputation as a seller.

Financial Strain

Maintaining an overpriced home on the market for an extended period can be financially draining. The longer your home stays unsold, the more you’ll spend on mortgage payments, utilities, maintenance, and taxes.


  • Carrying Costs: Ongoing costs can accumulate, reducing overall profit.
  • Financial Pressure: Increased financial pressure to lower the price or sell quickly.
  • Investment Loss: Potential loss of investment opportunities due to tied-up capital.

Legal and Ethical Considerations

Deliberately overpricing a home can raise legal and ethical concerns. Misrepresenting the value of your property can be seen as deceptive, and in some cases, may lead to legal issues.


  • Legal Repercussions: Risk of legal action if buyers feel misled.
  • Ethical Concerns: Ethical concerns over honesty and transparency.
  • Professional Relationships: Strained relationships with real estate professionals.

Tips for Selling Your Home Effectively

Conduct a Thorough Market Analysis

Work with a reputable real estate agent to conduct a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA). This will help you understand the market value of your home and set a realistic price.


  • Analyse Recent Sales: Review recent sales of similar properties in your area.
  • Assess Market Trends: Understand current market conditions and trends.
  • Consult Professionals: Seek advice from real estate professionals for accurate pricing.

Stage Your Home

Staging your home can enhance its appeal and perceived value. A well-staged home can attract more buyers and potentially justify a higher asking price.


  • Declutter and Depersonalise: Create a clean, neutral space that appeals to a broad audience.
  • Highlight Key Features: Showcase the home’s best features through effective staging.
  • Professional Photography: Use high-quality photos to enhance online listings.

Be Transparent

Honesty and transparency are crucial when selling your home. Be upfront about the property’s condition and any issues. This builds trust with buyers and can lead to smoother negotiations.


  • Full Disclosure: Provide full disclosure about the property’s condition.
  • Honest Marketing: Market the property honestly without overhyping.
  • Responsive Communication: Communicate openly and respond to buyer inquiries promptly.

“Get your Access to our Fully Customisable Investment Property Research and Analytics Tool Now!”

Consider Pre-Listing Inspections

A pre-listing inspection can identify potential issues before you list your home. Addressing these issues upfront can prevent surprises during the buyer’s inspection and support your asking price.


  • Hire an Inspector: Hire a qualified inspector for a thorough assessment.
  • Address Repairs: Fix any identified issues before listing, especially those that are outright noticeable.
  • Provide Reports: Share inspection reports with potential buyers for transparency.

Be Flexible with Showings

Make your home as accessible as possible for showings. The more people who can see your home, the higher the chances of receiving offers.


  • Flexible Scheduling: Allow for evening and weekend showings.
  • Open Houses: Host open houses to attract more buyers.
  • Well-Maintained: Keep the home clean and well-maintained for showings.

Selling your house for more than it’s worth is a strategy that comes with both potential rewards and significant risks. While it’s possible to achieve a higher profit, overpricing can lead to extended time on the market, appraisal issues, reduced buyer interest, and potential legal and ethical concerns. By conducting thorough market research, staging your home effectively, being transparent, and considering the current market conditions, you can make a more informed decision about how to price your home. Ultimately, working with a knowledgeable real estate agent and adopting a balanced approach will help you navigate the selling process successfully and achieve the best possible outcome.

More Resources

Is Buying a Property to Renovate Worth It

Buying a fixer-upper can be an exciting venture for those looking to dive into homeownership or property investment. The idea of purchasing a cheap...

Your Step-by-Step Guide in Qualifying for a Home Loan

Buying a home is a dream for many Australians, but before you can settle into your new space, you need to qualify for a...

Things to Ask Your Buyer’s Agent: A Guide for Homebuyers

Buying a home is one of the most significant investments you’ll ever make, and having a buyer’s agent can make the process smoother and...

Things to Look Out for in when Inspecting a Property to Buy

Investing in real estate can be a lucrative endeavor, but it requires a keen eye and due diligence to ensure you make a sound...